You Pick Coins by Type, Year, Mintmark, and Grade

Expand your Buffalo (Indian Head) Nickel collection today. You choose the year, mintmark, and grade of these nickels between 1920 and 1929. See photos for an example of each grade. Need multiple quantities of a specific date for jewelry / keepsake? Please reach out, I can make you a custom order. Extra Fine and above condition coins are listed...

Expand your Indian Head penny collection today. You choose the year, mintmark, and grade of these cents between 1890 and 1899.See photos for an example of each grade.Makes a great keepsake for a special birthday or event.                 

Expand your Indian Head penny collection today. You choose the year, mintmark, and grade of these cents between 1900 and 1909. See photos for an example of each grade. Makes a great keepsake for a special birthday or event. Need a 1908 S or 1909 S? Please see other listings; these are key dates and are priced individually based on the specific coin....

Expand your Lincoln wheat penny collection today. You choose the year, mintmark, and grade of these cents between 1909 and 1919. See photos for an example of each grade. Semi-key dates are available.

Expand your Lincoln wheat penny collection today. You choose the year, mintmark, and grade of these cents between 1920- and 1929. See photos for an example of each grade. Semi-key dates are available.

Expand your Lincoln wheat penny collection today. You choose the year, mintmark, and grade of these cents between 1930 and 1939. See photos for an example of each grade. Semi-key dates are available.

Expand your Lincoln wheat penny collection today. You choose the year, mintmark, and grade of these cents between 1940 and 1949. See photos for an example of each grade. Uncirculated coins sold individually. "Average Circulated" coins are only available as a 2 coin set with random selection of mintmarks. If you need a specific mintmark, please choose an...

Expand your Lincoln wheat penny collection today. You choose the year, mintmark, and grade of these cents between 1950 and 1958 (1958 is the final year for wheat pennies; the reverse was changed to the memorial design in 1959). See photos for an example of each grade. Uncirculated coins sold individually. "Average Circulated" coins are only available as...